Rating 5/10 – BottleBrief Rating System
Introduction
Henderson’s Best Amber Ale is the flagship beer from Henderson Brewing Co., a Toronto-based brewery that has made a name for itself by creating approachable, balanced beers with local inspiration. This amber ale is marketed as “a modern take on a classic English ale,” a nod to the brewing traditions that influenced much of Canada’s beer history. Designed to be refreshing and easy-drinking, Henderson’s Best sits at around 5.5% ABV and aims to offer a malt-forward character with a subtle floral nose and a touch of moderate hopping.
The brewery positions it as the beer that best represents what they’re about: balanced, flavourful, and accessible. While many craft breweries focus on bold IPAs or experimental brews, Henderson’s Best aims instead for timeless drinkability, the kind of beer you could imagine enjoying at a Toronto tavern in the 1800s. This review takes a closer look at how well it achieves that mission, whether it delivers on complexity, and how it stacks up against other ambers on the market.
Eye
Henderson’s Best presents itself beautifully in the glass, with a rich amber-to-copper tone that glows warmly when held to the light. The clarity is excellent, with no haze or cloudiness, which reinforces the impression of a carefully filtered ale. This visual clarity is often associated with traditional English-style ales, which prioritize drinkability and balance over unfiltered boldness.
The head is off-white and moderately foamy, forming a cap that initially looks promising but dissipates relatively quickly. Retention is not particularly strong, leaving only minimal lacing on the glass. While it doesn’t produce a dramatic or long-lasting crown of foam, it has a neat, clean look that reflects the beer’s straightforward style. The beer is visually appealing, but not eye-catching in a way that sets it apart from other ambers.
Nose
The aroma of Henderson’s Best is restrained but pleasant, leaning heavily on malt character with light accents from hops. At first sniff, caramel sweetness dominates, offering notes of toffee, biscuit, and gentle toasted bread. These malt-driven aromas evoke the warmth of baked goods, giving the beer a comforting presence.
Supporting these malt notes are subtle floral and earthy qualities from the hops, which don’t overwhelm but provide a balancing layer. The hop bouquet is mild and understated, likely from traditional English-style hop varieties, with whispers of herbs and faint spice. There may also be a touch of dried fruit — think raisins or prunes — which sometimes emerges in amber ales with yeast-forward fermentation. Overall, the nose is inviting, but not particularly bold; it provides a gentle preview of what’s to come rather than a striking aromatic punch.
Palate
The first sip of Henderson’s Best confirms what the nose suggests: a malt-driven beer that leans on caramel, bread, and subtle toasty flavours. The caramel sweetness hits upfront, coating the palate with a pleasant but somewhat one-dimensional note. This is followed by hints of biscuit and light toast, which add texture and stop the sweetness from feeling cloying.
As the beer develops on the tongue, a mild bitterness emerges, though it is soft and unobtrusive rather than sharp or commanding. This bitterness comes paired with faint floral and herbal tones, a sign of the hops at work, but they remain in the background rather than driving the flavour profile. The body is medium-light, smooth, and easy to drink. While this makes the beer refreshing and approachable, it also means it lacks complexity. The palate is enjoyable, but those seeking layered flavours or bold contrasts may find it underwhelming.
Finish
The finish of Henderson’s Best is clean and crisp, with a moderate drying effect that encourages another sip. After the initial malt sweetness fades, a gentle bitterness lingers on the tongue, leaving behind echoes of caramel and biscuit. This balance makes it drinkable, but not especially memorable.
The aftertaste is short to moderate in length, with malt flavours lasting slightly longer than the hops. There’s little evolution in the finish — no unexpected notes or layered complexity. Instead, it closes much as it began: malt-forward, lightly bitter, and straightforward. While this makes it accessible for casual drinkers, those looking for a finish that lingers or surprises may find themselves wanting more depth.
Conclusion
Henderson’s Best Amber Ale succeeds in delivering what it sets out to do: provide a balanced, malt-forward beer that’s easy to drink and reflective of English ale traditions. Its strengths lie in its accessibility and reliability. It’s the kind of beer you could serve to a wide range of people — from those who rarely drink craft beer to seasoned enthusiasts looking for something simple and clean. It has a nostalgic quality, evoking the type of pub beers that focus on comfort rather than experimentation.
However, from a craft beer enthusiast’s perspective, Henderson’s Best doesn’t push boundaries or leave a lasting impression. Its malt sweetness, mild hops, and crisp finish make it pleasant but not remarkable. Compared to other ambers that showcase bold caramelization, richer malt complexity, or punchier hop character, this one feels subdued. It lands firmly in the “good but not great” territory — a reliable companion, but not a standout. For those seeking something bolder or more distinctive, there are more compelling options available.
Summary
A reliable amber ale: malt and caramel forward, mild bitterness, clean finish. Good for casual sipping, less so for flavor complexity or boldness.
Category: Amber Ale / English-style Best Bitter influence
ABV: ~5.5%
Eye: amber-copper, clear, light head, modest retention
Nose: mild floral, caramel malt, light hop bouquet, subtle toast
Taste: caramel sweetness, bready malt, mild bitterness, soft yeast, slight dried fruit
Finish: moderately dry, lingering malt sweetness, faint bitterness, modest aftertaste
History and Fun Facts
Henderson Brewing Co. is a Toronto-based brewery founded in 2016, named after Robert Henderson, who is often credited as Toronto’s first brewer in the early 19th century. The brewery’s mission is to celebrate Toronto through beer, often drawing inspiration from local history, culture, and community stories. Henderson’s Best was one of the brewery’s first flagship releases and remains its most well-known product.
The beer has received recognition within the Canadian brewing scene, notably winning a Gold Medal at the 2020 Canadian Brewing Awards, which highlights its strength as a well-executed amber ale. Henderson Brewing also positions the beer as a modern homage to the kinds of ales that might have been brewed in Toronto in the 1800s, grounding it in a historical narrative while still making it accessible to modern palates.
Fun fact: Henderson Brewing has made a reputation for connecting beer to storytelling, with many of its brews named after Toronto events, landmarks, or cultural figures. Henderson’s Best, as their flagship, was designed to embody the brewery’s core ethos: balanced, approachable, and distinctly Torontonian. While it may not be the most adventurous beer, its local roots and historical tie-ins give it a cultural identity that resonates with Toronto drinkers.

